Gap between what private insurers and Medicare pay hospitals is growing
Skip to main content
MDHC_Logotype_white
Subscribe
  • My Account
  • Login
  • Subscribe
  • News
    • This Week's News
    • COVID-19
    • Providers
    • Insurance
    • Government
    • Finance
    • Technology
    • Safety & Quality
    • People
    • Regional News
    • Digital Edition
    • merrill goozner
      Healthcare groups should end all political donations—permanently
      Sticking to Mediterranean diet is good for the brain
      Joe Biden
      Revamp of the nation's vaccination effort may not be enough
      A man in a room with servers.
      Momentum grows to outsource hospital tech functions in 2021
    • COVID-19 hastens hospitals' revenue cycle outsourcing moves
      Operation Warp Speed Dr. Moncef Slaoui, Pfizer Group President Angela Hwang, Moderna CEO Stephane Bancel, CVS Health Executive Vice President Karen Lynch and McKesson CEO Brian Tyler participate in a panel discussion on the COVID-19 vaccine.
      Hospitals, drug companies strive to stand out virtually at JPM
      Dr. Bruce Siegel
      By protecting the healthcare safety net, Biden can put us on the path to a stronger country
      Joe Biden
      Revamp of the nation's vaccination effort may not be enough
    • The Check Up: Trenda Ray
      The Check Up: Trenda Ray of the University of Arkansas for Medical Sciences
      Trenda Ray
      Q&A: Arkansas nursing leader looking for creative staffing solutions as COVID cases surge
      Cook Lydia 4x6_i.jpg
      Northeast Ohio health systems increase community benefit values in 2019
      Vaccine rollout hits snag as health workers balk at shots
    • CMS approves rule forcing insurers to ease prior authorization
      COVID-19 still a big uncertainty for insurers in 2021
      Health insurers' outlook boosted after Dems' Georgia win
      humana_i.jpg
      Humana supports Ohio not-for-profits with $500,000
    • Joe Biden
      Revamp of the nation's vaccination effort may not be enough
      CMS will raise Medicare Advantage plan payments by 4.08% in 2022
      CMS approves rule forcing insurers to ease prior authorization
    • Operation Warp Speed Dr. Moncef Slaoui, Pfizer Group President Angela Hwang, Moderna CEO Stephane Bancel, CVS Health Executive Vice President Karen Lynch and McKesson CEO Brian Tyler participate in a panel discussion on the COVID-19 vaccine.
      Hospitals, drug companies strive to stand out virtually at JPM
      Intermountain, Trinity, Memorial Hermann behind $300M private equity fund
      Operation Warp Speed to bump up McKesson's stock price
      Reporter's notebook: J.P. Morgan's 2021 health conference
    • A man in a room with servers.
      Momentum grows to outsource hospital tech functions in 2021
      5 things to know about Google's $2.1B Fitbit acquisition
      Providence bets on machine-learning, consolidating data centers
      Mental health treatment was most common telehealth service during COVID
    • Sticking to Mediterranean diet is good for the brain
      Chance of COVID-19 triage care looms over Arizona hospitals
      U.S. ramps up vaccinations to get doses to more Americans
      367146427.jpg
      Should businesses mandate that staff get the COVID vaccine?
    • Cone Health CEO, CFO to depart amid pending Sentara merger
      Tower Health's finance chief resigning after years of steep losses
      AHRQ director Gopal Khanna resigns in response to Capitol riot
      Brigham president stepping down after Moderna controversy
    • Midwest
    • Northeast
    • South
    • West
  • Insights
    • ACA 10 Years After
    • Best Practices
    • InDepth Special Reports
    • Innovations
    • The Affordable Care Act after 10 years
    • New care model helps primary-care practices treat obesity
      doctor with patient
      COVID-19 treatment protocol developed in the field helps patients recover
      Rachel Wyatt
      Project to curb pressure injuries in hospitals shows promise
      Yale New Haven's COVID-19 nurse-staffing model has long-term benefits
    • Michellene Davis
      Healthcare leadership lacks the racial diversity needed to reduce health disparities
      Dr. James Hildreth
      How medical education can help fight racism
      Modern Healthcare InDepth: Breaking the bias that impedes better healthcare
      Videos: Healthcare industry executives describe their encounters with racism
      Quotes from rebadged employees
      Outsourcing IT, revenue cycle takes toll on internal culture
    • A woman with a wearable sensor talking to her provider.
      Wearable sensors help diagnose heart rhythm problems in West Virginia
      self service station
      COVID-19 pushes patient expectations toward self-service
      Targeting high-risk cancer patients with genetics
      A nurse holds up a phone with a message to a family member saying surgery has started.
      Texting, tablets help hospitals keep family updated on patient care
  • Transformation
    • Patients
    • Operations
    • Care Delivery
    • Payment
    • Highmark Health inks six-year cloud, tech deal with Google
      Study: 1 in 5 patients report discrimination when getting healthcare
      HHS proposes changing HIPAA privacy rules
      Android health records app launches at 230 health systems
    • California hospitals prepare ethical protocol to prioritize lifesaving care
      Amazon, JPMorgan Chase, Berkshire Hathaway disband Haven
      Digital pathways poised to reshape healthcare continuum in 2021
      Healthcare was the hardest hit by supply shortages across all U.S. industries
    • A woman with a wearable sensor talking to her provider.
      Wearable sensors help diagnose heart rhythm problems in West Virginia
      New care model helps primary-care practices treat obesity
      How hospitals are building on COVID-19 telehealth momentum
      Researchers: Hospital price variation exacerbates health inequities
    • MedPAC votes to boost hospital payments, freeze or cut other providers
      Most Next Gen ACOs achieved bonuses in 2019
      Congress recalibrates Medicare Physician Fee Schedule after lobbying
      CMS approves rule to encourage value-based drug pricing
  • Data/Lists
    • Rankings/Lists
    • Interactive Databases
    • Data Points
    • Health Systems Financials
      Executive Compensation
      Physician Compensation
  • Op-Ed
    • Bold Moves
    • Breaking Bias
    • Commentaries
    • Letters
    • Vital Signs Blog
    • From the Editor
    • Wellstar CEO calls adapting for the pandemic her bold move
      Howard P. Kern
      Recognizing the value of telehealth in its infancy
      Dr. Stephen Markovich
      A bold move helped take him from family doctor to OhioHealth CEO
      Dr. Bruce Siegel
      Why taking a hospital not-for-profit was Dr. Bruce Siegel’s boldest move
    • Barry Ostrowsky
      Ending racism is a journey taken together; the starting point must be now
      Laura Lee Hall and Gary Puckrein
      Increased flu vaccination has never been more important for communities of color
      John Daniels Jr.
      Health equity: Making the journey from buzzword to reality
      Mark C. Clement and David Cook
      We all need to 'do something' to fight inequities and get healthcare right, for every patient, every time
    • Dr. Bruce Siegel
      By protecting the healthcare safety net, Biden can put us on the path to a stronger country
      Healing healthcare: some ideas for triage by the new Congress, administration
      Dr. Sachin H. Jain
      Medicare for All? The better route to universal coverage would be Medicare Advantage for All
      Connectivity: a social determinant of health that can exacerbate all the others
    • Letters: Eliminating bias in healthcare needs to be ‘deliberate and organic’
      Letters: Maybe dropping out of ACOs is a good thing for patients
      Letters: White House and Congress share blame for lack of national COVID strategy
      Letters: VA making strides to improve state veterans home inspections
    • Sponsored Content Provided By Optum
      How blockchain could ease frustration with the payment process
      Sponsored Content Provided By Optum
      Three steps to better data-sharing for payer and provider CIOs
      Sponsored Content Provided By Optum
      Reduce total cost of care: 6 reasons why providers and payers should tackle the challenge together
      Sponsored Content Provided By Optum
      Why CIOs went from back-office operators to mission-critical innovators
  • Awards
    • Award Programs
    • Nominate
    • Previous Award Programs
    • Other Award Programs
    • Best Places to Work in Healthcare Logo for Navigation
      Nominations Open - Best Places to Work in Healthcare
      Nominations Open - Health Care Hall of Fame
      Nominations Open - 50 Most Influential Clinical Executives
    • 100 Most Influential People
    • 50 Most Influential Clinical Executives
    • Best Places to Work in Healthcare
    • Health Care Hall of Fame
    • Healthcare Marketing Impact Awards
    • Top 25 Emerging Leaders
    • Top 25 Innovators
    • Top 25 Minority Leaders
    • Top 25 Women Leaders
    • Excellence in Nursing Awards
    • Design Awards
    • Top 25 COOs in Healthcare
    • 100 Top Hospitals
    • ACHE Awards
  • Events
    • Conferences
    • Galas
    • Webinars
    • COVID-19 Event Tracker
    • Leadership Symposium
    • Healthcare Transformation Summit
    • Women Leaders in Healthcare Conference
    • Workplace of the Future Conference
    • Strategic Marketing Conference
    • Social Determinants of Health Symposium
    • Best Places to Work Awards Gala
    • Health Care Hall of Fame Gala
    • Top 25 Minority Leaders Gala (2022)
    • Top 25 Women Leaders Gala
  • Listen
    • Podcast - Next Up
    • Podcast - Beyond the Byline
    • Sponsored Podcast - Healthcare Insider
    • Video Series - The Check Up
    • Sponsored Video Series - One on One
    • Carter Dredge
      Next Up Podcast: Ready, set, innovate! Innovation and disruption in healthcare
      Next Up Podcast: COVID-19, social determinants highlight health inequities — what next?
      Ceci Connolly
      Next Up Podcast: How to navigate the murky post-election waters
      Next Up Podcast: Saving Rural Health
    • An older man wearing a mask receiving a vaccine.
      Beyond the Byline: Verifying information on the chaotic COVID-19 vaccine rollout
      doctor burnout
      Beyond the Byline: How healthcare supply chain struggles contribute to employee burnout
      Beyond the Byline: Covering race and diversity in the healthcare industry
      Beyond the Byline: How telehealth utilization has impacted investor-owned company earnings
    • Leading intention promote diversity and inclusion
      Introducing Healthcare Insider Podcast
    • The Check Up: Trenda Ray
      The Check Up: Trenda Ray of the University of Arkansas for Medical Sciences
      The Check Up: Dr. Kenneth Davis
      The Check Up: Dr. Kenneth Davis of Mount Sinai Health System
      The Check Up: Dr. Thomas McGinn
      The Check Up: Dr. Thomas McGinn of CommonSpirit Health
      The Check Up: Mark Ganz
      The Check Up: Mark Ganz of Cambia Health Solutions
    • Video: Ivana Naeymi Rad of Intelligent Medical Objects
  • MORE +
    • Advertise
    • Media Kit
    • Newsletters
    • Jobs
    • People on the Move
    • Reprints & Licensing
MENU
Transformation Hub

Where healthcare challenges find solutions

  • Patients
  • Operations
  • Care Delivery
  • Payment
Payment
September 18, 2020 12:01 AM

Gap between what private insurers and Medicare pay hospitals is growing

Tara Bannow
  • Tweet
  • Share
  • Share
  • Email
  • More
    Print
    Modern Healthcare Illustration / Getty Images

    A new study suggests that hospitals' market power may have a bigger influence on prices than oft-touted factors like compensating for Medicare and Medicaid losses and providing high-quality care.

    It's the third and largest iteration of not-for-profit think tank RAND Corp.'s deep dive into how much private insurers pay for inpatient and outpatient hospital services. It found private insurers paid hospitals on average 247% what Medicare would have for the same services in 2018, a gap that's creeped up in recent years and varies widely across states.

    The data calls into question the extent to which hospitals' higher commercial rates are set to offset losses on their government reimbursement, finding no correlation between the amount of publicly insured patients hospitals saw and their commercial prices.

    "Cost shifting is, I think, a useful rhetorical device that health systems use," said Katherine Hempstead, senior policy adviser with the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation, which sponsored the research. "But the truth is that in any negotiation, health systems are looking for the best price they can command, which often has more to do with their market power than what they need and the deficits they get from public payers."

    RAND's researchers drew upon $33.8 billion in spending from 3,112 hospitals nationally, including about 750,000 inpatient claims and 40.2 million outpatient claims between 2016 and 2018. The data, which researchers acknowledge covers only a sample of care provided in that time, come from self-insured employers, six state all-payer claims databases and claims submitted voluntarily by health insurers. The prices paid include patients' out-of-pocket costs, including deductibles and copayments.

    The finding that private plans paid 247% of what Medicare would have in 2018 is up from 230% in 2017 and 224% in 2016. If the private health plans included in the study had paid hospitals at Medicare rates, they would have paid $19.7 billion less between 2016 to 2018, a potential savings of 58%, the study said.

    Christopher Whaley, a policy researcher at RAND and the study's lead author, said it's fair that employers pay more for hospital services than government programs like Medicare and Medicaid, which pay below the cost of providing care. In 2018, Medicare paid hospitals 87 cents for every dollar they spent treating Medicare patients, according to the American Hospital Association. For Medicaid, that was 89 cents.

    However, if hospitals are truly upcharging based on that, Whaley said he would have expected to see facilities with more government patients charging private payers more, and those with fewer charging less. Depicted on a scatter graph, the dots should look like a 45-degree angle. Instead, the data points on the graph look like randomly placed dots across the chart.

    Whaley said he was surprised to find no correlation.

    "Which really suggests, combined with other studies, that sometimes hospitals charge high prices because they have the reputation or the quality or the market dominance to charge high prices, outside of these patient care factors," he said.

    The AHA has criticized previous versions of the RAND study. Tom Nickels, the trade group's executive vice president, said the latest version "again perpetuates erroneous suggestions that Medicare payments should be used as a benchmark for private insurers," despite reimbursing below cost. Nickels also said the study uses a "hand-picked sample of employers and insurers," whose claims represent just 0.7% of inpatient admissions and 1.8% of outpatient visits over the study period.

    "The case for pulling resources from care providers was weak from the start," he said. "It is beyond reckless to advance this approach now."

    RAND's study also examined whether higher prices correlated with higher CMS star ratings and better safety scores from the Leapfrog Group. It found that among high-priced hospitals—those whose relative prices were 2.5 times that of Medicare—20% received five-star CMS ratings and 4% received one star. Among lower-priced hospitals—those with relative prices below 1.5 times Medicare—just 2% received five stars and 1% received one star.

    At the same time, the study noted that so-called "high-value hospitals," those offering low prices and high quality based on their star ratings, do exist: 91% of lower-priced hospitals received three or more stars. Further, 17% of higher-priced hospitals received one or two stars, compared with 10% for lower-priced hospitals.

    Among the 71% of hospitals in the study that had Leapfrog scores, the high-priced ones tended to have the same safety grades as their lower-priced counterparts, the study found.

    Gloria Sachdev, CEO of the Employers' Forum of Indiana, said it's instructive for employers to know there are high-quality hospitals with low and medium prices. Now, employers need to use tactics like narrow networks or reference pricing in their health plans to steer employees toward those facilities.

    "That's what we need to start catering to really aggressively," Sachdev said. "We need to start saying, 'Here's the best quality at the best price,' and developing benefit models that steer patients and incentivize people to use high quality, low cost facilities."

    The Employers' Forum of Indiana, a multi-stakeholder business coalition whose members include Chrysler and Cummins, commissioned the new study and its two previous versions with the goal of helping members lower their healthcare costs. The previous research has helped numerous members enter narrow networks, tired networks and direct contracting with hospitals, Sachdev said. Some are considering centers of excellence and reference pricing.

    The study lists Parkview Health in Fort Wayne, Indiana as the second most expensive between 2016 and 2018, with a relative price of 388% of Medicare for inpatient and outpatient services. Relative prices are the ratio of private amounts paid divided by the Medicare allowed amounts for the same services. Sachdev said health insurer Anthem, in partnership with employers, was able to negotiate lower prices with Parkview after a previous version of RAND's article showed it was expensive relative to its peers.

    Parkview CEO Mike Packnett said in a statement the RAND study uses data that predates its new agreements with several major insurers and direct-to-employer contracts. It also doesn't include price reductions the system made to common outpatient services.

    Packnett also said affordability requires a much broader focus that looks at value.

    "We understand that the report's authors agree that in order to fully measure hospital value, one would have to consider other factors, including patient outcomes and utilization, which are not reflected in the rankings," he said.

    If employers' own use of the data doesn't put enough of a dent in healthcare spending, it might show the need for policy solutions, such as rate setting or a public option, Hempstead said.

    "It's the only real industry that can go to purchasers and say, 'It's your job to cover our costs. It's not our job to reduce our costs,'" she said.

    The study lists John Muir Health in the San Francisco Bay Area as the most expensive health system, with a relative price of 401% of Medicare. The two-hospital system said in a statement that the study drew on less than one-quarter of 1% of its roughly 1.2 million inpatient and outpatient cases between 2016 and 2018. John Muir also said its operating margin has consistently held at 3% or lower, and its reimbursement from Medicare and Medicaid are well below the cost of care.

    Orlando Health was third on the list, at 374% of Medicare. In a statement, the health system said the study included less than one-quarter of 1% of Orlando Health's 3.9 million admissions and outpatient services during the study period.

    "If Rand were to use a more appropriately sized data base, the results would show Orlando Health's rates are lower than others in the state, while our quality remains high," the statement said.

    Whaley explained that fewer Florida employers contributed to the study than those in other states, which explains why Orlando Health's sample size is smaller. Its relative price is based on 86 inpatient stays and about 700 outpatient services.

    The study covers 49 states plus Washington, D.C. Maryland was excluded because of its all-payer hospital rate setting system. RAND's previous version of the study included 25 states, and the first version focused only on Indiana.

    Unlike previous versions, this study includes physicians' professional fees in addition to hospitals' facility fees. The study found that, on average, 13% of the overall hospital price difference relative to Medicare was driven by professional fees, with wide variation by state. In Minnesota, professional fees were 378% of Medicare, compared to 259% for facility fees. In West Virginia and Indiana, professional fees much lower than the facility fees.

    Dr. Michael Richards, associate professor of economics at Baylor University, said he was surprised to see that hospitals' average markup on the outpatient side was actually higher than on the inpatient side. Richards, who reviewed the study prior to publication, said that's important because people often think of outpatient care as being less expensive, but that may not always be the case.

    Richards said in his mind, the new RAND study highlights the value of promoting competition from a policy standpoint. He said the opposite is happening in Texas, where lawmakers last year passed a law that lets the state green light hospital mergers the federal government would deem anticompetitive. In fact, the Federal Trade Commission is urging Texas regulators to block two mergers currently being sought under the new law.

    "While we're seeing consolidation and more evidence of negative downstream consequences of consolidation, our policies seem to be more promoting consolidation as opposed to promoting competition," Richards said.

    Tags: Payment, This Week in Healthcare, Not-For-Profit, For-Profit Hospitals, Price transparency, CMS star ratings, Leapfrog Group, Private Plans, Payment, Transformation, Transformation Hub
    Letter
    to the
    Editor

    Send us a letter

    Have an opinion about this story? Click here to submit a Letter to the Editor, and we may publish it in print.

    Recommended for You
    MedPAC votes to boost hospital payments, freeze or cut other providers
    MedPAC votes to boost hospital payments, freeze or cut other providers
    Most Next Gen ACOs achieved bonuses in 2019
    Most Next Gen ACOs achieved bonuses in 2019
    Sponsored Content
    Get Free Newsletters

    Sign up for free enewsletters and alerts to receive breaking news and in-depth coverage of healthcare events and trends, as they happen, right to your inbox.

    Subscribe Today

    The weekly magazine, websites, research and databases provide a powerful and all-encompassing industry presence. We help you make informed business decisions and lead your organizations to success.

    Subscribe
    Connect with Us
    • LinkedIn
    • Twitter
    • Facebook
    • RSS
    • Instagram

    Stay Connected

    Join the conversation with Modern Healthcare through our social media pages

    MDHC_Logotype_white
    Contact Us

    (877) 812-1581

    Email us

     

    Resources
    • Contact Us
    • Advertise with Us
    • Ad Choices Ad Choices
    • Sitemap
    Editorial Dept
    • Submission Guidelines
    • Code of Ethics
    • Awards
    • About Us
    Legal
    • Terms and Conditions
    • Privacy Policy
    • Privacy Request
    Modern Healthcare
    Copyright © 1996-2021. Crain Communications, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
    • News
      • This Week's News
      • COVID-19
      • Providers
      • Insurance
      • Government
      • Finance
      • Technology
      • Safety & Quality
      • People
      • Regional News
        • Midwest
        • Northeast
        • South
        • West
      • Digital Edition
    • Insights
      • ACA 10 Years After
      • Best Practices
      • InDepth Special Reports
      • Innovations
    • Transformation
      • Patients
      • Operations
      • Care Delivery
      • Payment
    • Data/Lists
      • Rankings/Lists
      • Interactive Databases
      • Data Points
    • Op-Ed
      • Bold Moves
      • Breaking Bias
      • Commentaries
      • Letters
      • Vital Signs Blog
      • From the Editor
    • Awards
      • Award Programs
        • 100 Most Influential People
        • 50 Most Influential Clinical Executives
        • Best Places to Work in Healthcare
        • Health Care Hall of Fame
        • Healthcare Marketing Impact Awards
        • Top 25 Emerging Leaders
        • Top 25 Innovators
        • Top 25 Minority Leaders
        • Top 25 Women Leaders
      • Nominate
      • Previous Award Programs
        • Excellence in Nursing Awards
        • Design Awards
        • Top 25 COOs in Healthcare
      • Other Award Programs
        • 100 Top Hospitals
        • ACHE Awards
    • Events
      • Conferences
        • Leadership Symposium
        • Healthcare Transformation Summit
        • Women Leaders in Healthcare Conference
        • Workplace of the Future Conference
        • Strategic Marketing Conference
        • Social Determinants of Health Symposium
      • Galas
        • Best Places to Work Awards Gala
        • Health Care Hall of Fame Gala
        • Top 25 Minority Leaders Gala (2022)
        • Top 25 Women Leaders Gala
      • Webinars
      • COVID-19 Event Tracker
    • Listen
      • Podcast - Next Up
      • Podcast - Beyond the Byline
      • Sponsored Podcast - Healthcare Insider
      • Video Series - The Check Up
      • Sponsored Video Series - One on One
    • MORE +
      • Advertise
      • Media Kit
      • Newsletters
      • Jobs
      • People on the Move
      • Reprints & Licensing