Healthcare price growth significantly outpaces inflation
Healthcare prices continue to rise across the country, according to a new study.
Over a five-year period, healthcare prices increased in 111 out of 112 metro areas analyzed by the Health Care Cost Institute. The outlier was Durham-Chapel Hill, N.C., where prices dropped 5% from 2012 to 2016, HCCI's analysis of 1.78 billion commercial health insurance claims showed.
Healthcare prices grew about 16% over that period, which was about three times the inflation rate, said Bill Johnson, the author of the report and senior researcher at HCCI.
"Prices aren't going down virtually anywhere, no matter where you are looking," he said.
There was wide variation across markets as prices of inpatient, outpatient and professional services increased or decreased at different rates.
In Green Bay, Wis., for instance, physician and other ambulatory-care prices were 43% higher than the national average, while inpatient and outpatient prices were 16% and 7% lower. In El Paso, Texas, the opposite was true—professional services prices were 19% lower than the national benchmark, and inpatient and outpatient prices were 21% higher.
In 2016, 88 markets were at or below the national average. Durham-Chapel Hill's price levels, for instance, were 16% below the national average. The lowest, Baltimore, was 33% lower than the national average while Anchorage, Alaska, and San Jose, Calif., were 65% higher. That means that prices in San Jose were 2.5 times those in Baltimore.
Notably, several major outliers like Alaska, San Jose and San Francisco were well above the national average, dramatically inflating the average.
Price levels and growth were not necessarily related, researchers found. Prices in Tampa, Fla., grew more than any other area since 2012, 21%, but were 3% lower than the national average in 2016. New York, however, had similar price growth, but had prices 10% higher than the national benchmark because of its higher starting point.
The data reinforce that all healthcare is local, Johnson said. Price variation cannot be attributed to one factor, he said.
"We thought there might be one or two commonalities behind why prices were high, but that wasn't the case," Johnson said.
While the report doesn't dig into drivers of cost variation, many economists have pinned higher prices on a lack of competition. Health systems that dominate a market can enter into "all or nothing" contracts with insurers that inflate prices, experts said. Insurers could exert similar pressure when they have fewer competitors.
Still, the number of competitors in a given market may be less important than the type of competitors, research shows. Prices may be higher when markets don't coordinate care and share data, analysts said. Healthcare institutions that have higher built-in costs related to 24/7 emergency services, specialized equipment and services as well as research and education can also drive prices higher.
Future HCCI studies will delve deeper into provider competition, service use, total spending and waste, said Kevin Kennedy, an HCCI researcher.
"We hope this data directs stakeholders and policymakers and gives them the right mindset as they look to affect healthcare pricing," he said.
Send us a letter
Have an opinion about this story? Click here to submit a Letter to the Editor, and we may publish it in print.