Judge explains the flip-flop that spiked NorthShore-Advocate deal
Skip to main content
Sister Publication Links
  • Modern Healthcare Metrics
MDHC_Logotype_white
Subscribe
  • Subscribe
  • Register
  • Login
  • News
    • This Week's News
    • Providers
    • Insurance
    • Government
    • Finance
    • Technology
    • Safety & Quality
    • People
    • Regional News
    • Digital Edition
    • Poor moms struggle with prenatal care in some states
      Northwell Health pledges $1 million investment in gun violence prevention
      Optum subsidiary Surgical Care Affiliates names new CEO
      Surprise billing package aims to end secrecy of provider-insurer contracts
    • Northwell Health pledges $1 million investment in gun violence prevention
      Tenet selling two Memphis area hospitals to Methodist Le Bonheur
      HealthPartners sheds more than 400 jobs across three rounds of cuts
      Kaiser Permanente seeks to address trauma in 25,000 schools by 2023
    • Michigan Blues makes deals with seven health organizations aiming to bend cost curve
      ACA exchange enrollment lags as deadline nears
      Plan members unlikely to benefit from Supreme Court risk corridor battle
      Joan Budden
      Q&A: Priority Health CEO eager to share best practices with Total Health Care
    • Poor moms struggle with prenatal care in some states
      CMS to repay hospitals for doctor's visits
      Capitol Building with pills
      Week Ahead: House to vote on drug bill; SCOTUS hears risk-corridor case
      MedPAC thinks hospice payments are too high
    • Analysts to CommonSpirit Health: Show us the savings
      Smallest hospitals saw biggest earnings gains last month
      Sutter Health postpones financial filing
      doctor helping patient stock image Sandoz
      Sponsored Content Provided By Sandoz
      As hospital executives look to reduce costs, biosimilars offer a compelling option
    • astronaut
      Astronauts developed bloodstream issues in space
      Sponsored Content Provided By ABM Healthcare
      Protecting and Maintaining Medical Devices
      human hand robotic hand stock image
      Sponsored Content Provided By Deloitte
      The Health System of the Future: How Digital Health Technology is Transforming Care
      EHR
      EHR vendors most in-use throughout Medicare incentive program
    • Hospitals need more than HCAHPS to measure patient experience, report says
      Promising greater safety, a tiny widget creates chaos for tube feeders
      IHI releases principles for improving patient safety measures
      MRIs of dense breasts find more cancer but also false alarms
    • Optum subsidiary Surgical Care Affiliates names new CEO
      Detroit Medical Center CEO Tony Tedeschi to retire; Audrey Gregory to succeed him
      Community Health Systems' CFO to retire at end of year
      Kaiser Permanente names Gregory Adams CEO
    • Midwest
    • Northeast
    • South
    • West
  • Special Features
    • Best Practices
    • InDepth Special Reports
    • Innovations
    • Chest x-ray from a patient with a vaping-related lung injury
      Vaping-related cases lead to care guidelines from Intermountain
      Arkansas Children’s was a founding partner in Solutions for Patient Safety.
      Children's hospitals collaborate rather than compete on patient safety
      Peer recovery specialists at St. Barnabas Medical Center work with nurse Brenna Zarra.
      Peer recovery helping patients with addiction seek treatment
      UNC Health Care trains staff to treat dementia patients
    • Linda Kenney
      Patient advocate recalls two medical errors that nearly killed her
      Betsy Lehman
      Recent safety scandals suggest healthcare leaders haven't learned lessons
      Doctors and nurse with patient
      20 years after 'To Err is Human,' hospital care quality measures are still of little use
      Dr. Christine Cassel
      To err is human. That’s still true 20 years later, but some solutions to the problem aren’t helping
    • Advanced ICU Care
      Telemedicine helps rural hospitals meet intensivist shortage
      Randy Oostra, CEO of ProMedica
      HCR ManorCare deal laid foundation for ProMedica’s growth
      Paging Dr. Robot: Artificial intelligence moves into care
      A child being screened for vision problems using a smartphone.
      App screens kids for eye problems before they can talk
  • Transformation
    • Patients
    • Operations
    • Care Delivery
    • Payment
    • ProMedica doubles down on social needs data analysis
      Amazon taps first pharmacy for Alexa Rx management
      Trump administration unveils new price transparency rules
      A child being screened for vision problems using a smartphone.
      App screens kids for eye problems before they can talk
    • California's landmark privacy law will have 'subtle' effect on hospitals
      Health systems weigh return on investment as they ramp up tech
      VA dives into artificial intelligence R&D
      Home health to pare down therapy services, up telehealth offerings
    • Chest x-ray from a patient with a vaping-related lung injury
      Vaping-related cases lead to care guidelines from Intermountain
      Advanced ICU Care
      Telemedicine helps rural hospitals meet intensivist shortage
      Peer recovery specialists at St. Barnabas Medical Center work with nurse Brenna Zarra.
      Peer recovery helping patients with addiction seek treatment
      UNC Health Care trains staff to treat dementia patients
    • Surprise billing package aims to end secrecy of provider-insurer contracts
      CMS to repay hospitals for doctor's visits
      Chart reviews boost Medicare Advantage payments by $6.7 billion, OIG finds
      Value-based pay still struggles to improve costs, quality
  • Data/Lists
    • Rankings/Lists
    • Data Points
    • Modern Healthcare Metrics
  • Op-Ed
    • Bold Moves
    • Breaking Bias
    • Commentaries
    • Letters
    • Vital Signs Blog
    • From the Editor
    • Randy Oostra, CEO of ProMedica
      HCR ManorCare deal laid foundation for ProMedica’s growth
      Steve Strongwater
      How Atrius Health stayed independent by not shying away from risk
      Why moving the VA to a new EHR was a pivotal decision
      Why AdventHealth's rebrand was more than a name change
    • Terry Shaw
      A diverse and inclusive culture should empower others
      Paving the path to diversity and inclusion
      The next step in healthcare evolution
      Breaking Bias: A road map to boost women and minorities into healthcare leadership
    • Dr. Richard Snyder
      Outdated privacy laws hinder coordinated care, especially in the fight against addiction
      David Dill and Keith Myers
      Healthcare partnerships are a proven path to better care, healthier communities
      Health systems need to devote more resources to caring for the caregivers
      Chip Kahn and Alan Morgan
      Rural healthcare needs innovation, policy changes to survive
    • Letters: Let’s keep humanity in discussions about patient safety
      Hospital with money
      Letters: Let providers set their prices,
 and then publish them all
      Letters: Ambulatory surgery centers aren't getting a break on regulation
      Letters: Rising Medicaid spending isn't a windfall for providers
    • Sponsored Content Provided By Optum
      How blockchain could ease frustration with the payment process
      Sponsored Content Provided By Optum
      Three steps to better data-sharing for payer and provider CIOs
      Sponsored Content Provided By Optum
      Reduce total cost of care: 6 reasons why providers and payers should tackle the challenge together
      Sponsored Content Provided By Optum
      Why CIOs went from back-office operators to mission-critical innovators
  • Awards
    • Nominate
    • Award Programs
    • Previous Award Programs
    • Other Award Programs
    • Nominations Open - Top 25 Minority Leaders
      Nominations Open - Health Care Hall of Fame
    • 100 Most Influential People
    • 50 Most Influential Clinical Executives
    • Best Places to Work in Healthcare
    • Health Care Hall of Fame
    • Healthcare Marketing Impact Awards
    • Top 25 Emerging Leaders
    • Top 25 Innovators
    • Top 25 Minority Leaders
    • Top 25 Women Leaders
    • Excellence in Nursing Awards
    • Design Awards
    • Top 25 COOs in Healthcare
    • 100 Top Hospitals
    • ACHE Awards
  • Events
    • Conferences
    • Galas
    • Webinars
    • Leadership Symposium
    • Healthcare Transformation Summit
    • Critical Connections: Social Determinants of Health Symposium
    • Women Leaders in Healthcare Conference
    • Workplace of the Future Conference
    • Strategic Marketing Conference
    • Health Care Hall of Fame Gala
    • Top 25 Women Leaders Gala
    • Best Places to Work Awards Gala
    • Top 25 Minority Leaders Gala (2020)
  • MORE +
    • Advertise
    • Media Kit
    • Newsletters
    • Jobs
    • People on the Move
    • Reprints & Licensing
MENU
Breadcrumb
  1. Home
  2. Finance
March 16, 2017 01:00 AM

Judge explains the flip-flop that spiked NorthShore-Advocate deal

Kristen Schorsch, Crain's Chicago Business
  • Tweet
  • Share
  • Share
  • Email
  • More
    Print

    A federal judge explained in a new court filing today why he switched from siding with two large suburban health systems that wanted to merge to favoring antitrust regulators that fought the union.

    It was a stunning reversal March 7 that led to the demise of the proposed marriage between Advocate Health Care of Downers Grove, already the largest hospital network in Illinois, and Evanston-based NorthShore University HealthSystem. Combined, they would have created the 11th largest nonprofit hospital system in the nation.

    In the redacted filing, U.S. District Court Judge Jorge Alonso's decision essentially boiled down to this: If he allowed the systems to merge, it might have been harder to break them up later and "recreate pre-merger competition."

    Through a spokeswoman, NorthShore declined to comment. In a statement, a spokeswoman for Advocate said: "We move forward committed to the same core values that drove our decision to pursue the merger—improve quality, advance care delivery and lower costs."

    In the filing, Alonso ticked off a host of reasons for why he ultimately changed his mind. He was forced to reconsider his ruling after the 7th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in October ruled that his decision not to pause the proposed merger over antitrust concerns was "erroneously flawed."

    Among the highlights in today's filing:

    — While some insurers said they couldn't sell a health plan to employers without both Advocate and NorthShore hospitals in the network, the hospitals argued the carriers' testimony, especially that of dominant Blue Cross & Blue Shield of Illinois, should be taken skeptically because they have competitive reasons for blocking it.

    It's not so clear cut, Alonso wrote today: "The Court shares some of defendants' concerns about the credibility of the insurers' testimony, which may indeed be self-serving, but even taking their testimony with a grain of salt, the record as a whole supports the view that insurers genuinely believe that a plan that excludes Advocate and NorthShore is not viable in the North Shore Area."

    Still, he added that some insurers' testimony in support of the merger wasn't credible. "In some cases, what lukewarm support the insurers mustered was expressed in terms of hope rather than expectation. The insurers are not in a position to know precisely how the merger will affect consumer welfare." They might have supported the merger believing doing so would improve their own competitive positions, Alonso wrote.

    — Though the aspiring merger partners view prominent medical centers such as Northwestern Memorial Hospital in downtown Streeterville and Rush University Medical Center on the Near West Side as rivals, they are so-called "destination hospitals," Alonso noted. That's because they can't fill insurers' need for a hospital that provides local care on the North Shore, he said. The definition of the North Shore market was a key element of the original dispute.

    — On the Advocate and NorthShore's criticism of the FTC's finding that the merger would harm consumers by hiking the cost of medical care, Alonso called the systems' critique "desultory and superficial, and therefore unconvincing."

    — On Advocate not being able to offer its own health plan to employers without expanding east of Interstate 94, getting into NorthShore's territory: "In fact one employer has quite successfully done so: Advocate itself," Alonso wrote.

    Read the judge order here.

    "Judge explains the flip-flop that spiked NorthShore-Advocate deal" originally appeared on Crain's Chicago Business.

    Letter
    to the
    Editor

    Send us a letter

    Have an opinion about this story? Click here to submit a Letter to the Editor, and we may publish it in print.

    Recommended for You
    Sponsored Content
    Get Free Newsletters

    Sign up for free enewsletters and alerts to receive breaking news and in-depth coverage of healthcare events and trends, as they happen, right to your inbox.

    Subscribe Today

    The weekly magazine, websites, research and databases provide a powerful and all-encompassing industry presence. We help you make informed business decisions and lead your organizations to success.

    Subscribe
    Connect with Us
    • LinkedIn
    • Twitter
    • Facebook
    • RSS
    • Instagram

    Stay Connected

    Join the conversation with Modern Healthcare through our social media pages

    MDHC_Logotype_white
    Contact Us

    (877) 812-1581

    Email us

     

    Resources
    • Contact Us
    • Advertise with Us
    • Ad Choices Ad Choices
    • Sitemap
    Editorial Dept
    • Submission Guidelines
    • Code of Ethics
    • Awards
    • About Us
    Legal
    • Terms and Conditions
    • Privacy Policy
    Modern Healthcare
    Copyright © 1996-2019. Crain Communications, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
    • News
      • This Week's News
      • Providers
      • Insurance
      • Government
      • Finance
      • Technology
      • Safety & Quality
      • People
      • Regional News
        • Midwest
        • Northeast
        • South
        • West
      • Digital Edition
    • Special Features
      • Best Practices
      • InDepth Special Reports
      • Innovations
    • Transformation
      • Patients
      • Operations
      • Care Delivery
      • Payment
    • Data/Lists
      • Rankings/Lists
      • Data Points
      • Modern Healthcare Metrics
    • Op-Ed
      • Bold Moves
      • Breaking Bias
      • Commentaries
      • Letters
      • Vital Signs Blog
      • From the Editor
    • Awards
      • Nominate
      • Award Programs
        • 100 Most Influential People
        • 50 Most Influential Clinical Executives
        • Best Places to Work in Healthcare
        • Health Care Hall of Fame
        • Healthcare Marketing Impact Awards
        • Top 25 Emerging Leaders
        • Top 25 Innovators
        • Top 25 Minority Leaders
        • Top 25 Women Leaders
      • Previous Award Programs
        • Excellence in Nursing Awards
        • Design Awards
        • Top 25 COOs in Healthcare
      • Other Award Programs
        • 100 Top Hospitals
        • ACHE Awards
    • Events
      • Conferences
        • Leadership Symposium
        • Healthcare Transformation Summit
        • Critical Connections: Social Determinants of Health Symposium
        • Women Leaders in Healthcare Conference
        • Workplace of the Future Conference
        • Strategic Marketing Conference
      • Galas
        • Health Care Hall of Fame Gala
        • Top 25 Women Leaders Gala
        • Best Places to Work Awards Gala
        • Top 25 Minority Leaders Gala (2020)
      • Webinars
    • MORE +
      • Advertise
      • Media Kit
      • Newsletters
      • Jobs
      • People on the Move
      • Reprints & Licensing