Aetna jeopardized its antitrust case and the ACA by exiting some exchanges
Skip to main content
MDHC_Logotype_white
Subscribe
  • My Account
  • Login
  • Subscribe
  • News
    • This Week's News
    • COVID-19
    • Providers
    • Insurance
    • Government
    • Finance
    • Technology
    • Safety & Quality
    • People
    • Regional News
    • Digital Edition
    • Biden more bullish on vaccines, open to 1.5M daily shot goal
      Billing, antitrust exemption changes upend negotiations between insurers and providers
      Few nursing home residents have received second COVID-19 vaccine dose
      Fresenius building renal genomic registry to inform precision care for kidney disease
    • Biden more bullish on vaccines, open to 1.5M daily shot goal
      Few nursing home residents have received second COVID-19 vaccine dose
      The missing piece in our fight against COVID-19: primary care
      Google to convert office space for COVID-19 vax clinics
    • Ascension’s St. Mary’s Hospital Surgery Center at Towne Centre and Allegheny Health Network’s Bethel Park surgery center
      Hospitals see opportunity, risk in ambulatory surgery centers
      Health suffers as rural hospitals close
      Medicare ACO participants fell in 2021
      Louisiana gets reports vaccine providers are discriminating
    • Billing, antitrust exemption changes upend negotiations between insurers and providers
      MAIN-Health Bill_iStock_i.jpg
      Insurance-tech firm MultiPlan makes $155M buy after blank-check deal
      Last-minute COVID costs cut into UnitedHealthcare's $396 million operating income
      CMS approves rule forcing insurers to ease prior authorization
    • It's a secret: California keeps key virus data from public
      lacewell_linda_supertinendent_dept_of_financial_services_8.47.jpg
      New York state investigates drug price spikes during pandemic
      Health experts blame rapid expansion for vaccine shortages
      HHS freezes rule targeting community health centers' drug discounts
    • KPMG says deal activity will stay high in '21: 10 takeaways
      By the Numbers: 20 largest healthcare investment banks in 2020
      Providers await new HHS coronavirus grant reporting deadline
      Operation Warp Speed Dr. Moncef Slaoui, Pfizer Group President Angela Hwang, Moderna CEO Stephane Bancel, CVS Health Executive Vice President Karen Lynch and McKesson CEO Brian Tyler participate in a panel discussion on the COVID-19 vaccine.
      Hospitals, drug companies strive to stand out virtually at JPM
    • Google to convert office space for COVID-19 vax clinics
      Dr. Karen DeSalvo
      Next Up Podcast: What to expect with telehealth and healthcare technology in the next four years
      Next Up Podcast: What to expect with telehealth and healthcare technology in the next 4 years - Transcript
      A man in a room with servers.
      Momentum grows to outsource hospital tech functions in 2021
    • China pushes conspiracy theories on COVID origin, vaccines
      An older man wearing a mask receiving a vaccine.
      Want more diversity in clinical trials? Start with the researchers
      Avocado
      Avocado a day keeps the doctor away
      50% of Americans make resolutions. Fewer than 27% keep them over time.
      Data Points: Sticking with your resolutions
    • WEb_i.jpg
      Q&A: Dr. Cliff Megerian, University Hospitals' soon-to-be CEO
      ZentyWeb_i.jpg
      Tom Zenty is leaving a legacy of transformational growth at University Hospitals
      Cerner names Erceg as new CFO
      Elizabeth Richter will serve as acting CMS administrator
    • Midwest
    • Northeast
    • South
    • West
  • Insights
    • ACA 10 Years After
    • Best Practices
    • InDepth Special Reports
    • Innovations
    • The Affordable Care Act after 10 years
    • New care model helps primary-care practices treat obesity
      doctor with patient
      COVID-19 treatment protocol developed in the field helps patients recover
      Rachel Wyatt
      Project to curb pressure injuries in hospitals shows promise
      Yale New Haven's COVID-19 nurse-staffing model has long-term benefits
    • Dr. James Hildreth
      How medical education can help fight racism
      Modern Healthcare InDepth: Breaking the bias that impedes better healthcare
      Videos: Healthcare industry executives describe their encounters with racism
      Michellene Davis
      Healthcare leadership lacks the racial diversity needed to reduce health disparities
      Quotes from rebadged employees
      Outsourcing IT, revenue cycle takes toll on internal culture
    • A phone screen showing the question, "Mary we hope this information was helpful and we'd like to keep guiding you. Are you interested in knowing when it's your turn to receive the vaccine?"
      Chatbots, texting campaigns help manage influx of COVID vax questions
      A woman with a wearable sensor talking to her provider.
      Wearable sensors help diagnose heart rhythm problems in West Virginia
      self service station
      COVID-19 pushes patient expectations toward self-service
      Targeting high-risk cancer patients with genetics
  • Transformation
    • Patients
    • Operations
    • Care Delivery
    • Payment
    • Highmark Health inks six-year cloud, tech deal with Google
      Study: 1 in 5 patients report discrimination when getting healthcare
      HHS proposes changing HIPAA privacy rules
      Android health records app launches at 230 health systems
    • California hospitals prepare ethical protocol to prioritize lifesaving care
      Amazon, JPMorgan Chase, Berkshire Hathaway disband Haven
      Digital pathways poised to reshape healthcare continuum in 2021
      Healthcare was the hardest hit by supply shortages across all U.S. industries
    • A phone screen showing the question, "Mary we hope this information was helpful and we'd like to keep guiding you. Are you interested in knowing when it's your turn to receive the vaccine?"
      Chatbots, texting campaigns help manage influx of COVID vax questions
      A woman with a wearable sensor talking to her provider.
      Wearable sensors help diagnose heart rhythm problems in West Virginia
      New care model helps primary-care practices treat obesity
      How hospitals are building on COVID-19 telehealth momentum
    • Regional insurers bet big on virtual-first plans
      MedPAC votes to boost hospital payments, freeze or cut other providers
      Most Next Gen ACOs achieved bonuses in 2019
      Congress recalibrates Medicare Physician Fee Schedule after lobbying
  • Data/Lists
    • Rankings/Lists
    • Interactive Databases
    • Data Points
    • Health Systems Financials
      Executive Compensation
      Physician Compensation
  • Op-Ed
    • Bold Moves
    • Breaking Bias
    • Commentaries
    • Letters
    • Vital Signs Blog
    • From the Editor
    • Wellstar CEO calls adapting for the pandemic her bold move
      Howard P. Kern
      Recognizing the value of telehealth in its infancy
      Dr. Stephen Markovich
      A bold move helped take him from family doctor to OhioHealth CEO
      Dr. Bruce Siegel
      Why taking a hospital not-for-profit was Dr. Bruce Siegel’s boldest move
    • Barry Ostrowsky
      Ending racism is a journey taken together; the starting point must be now
      Laura Lee Hall and Gary Puckrein
      Increased flu vaccination has never been more important for communities of color
      John Daniels Jr.
      Health equity: Making the journey from buzzword to reality
      Mark C. Clement and David Cook
      We all need to 'do something' to fight inequities and get healthcare right, for every patient, every time
    • The missing piece in our fight against COVID-19: primary care
      Ambulatory surgery centers offer extraordinary value in a high-cost healthcare system
       Alan B. Miller
      Looking ahead with optimism as we continue to transform healthcare
      Dr. Bruce Siegel
      By protecting the healthcare safety net, Biden can put us on the path to a stronger country
    • Letters: Eliminating bias in healthcare needs to be ‘deliberate and organic’
      Letters: Maybe dropping out of ACOs is a good thing for patients
      Letters: White House and Congress share blame for lack of national COVID strategy
      Letters: VA making strides to improve state veterans home inspections
    • Sponsored Content Provided By Optum
      How blockchain could ease frustration with the payment process
      Sponsored Content Provided By Optum
      Three steps to better data-sharing for payer and provider CIOs
      Sponsored Content Provided By Optum
      Reduce total cost of care: 6 reasons why providers and payers should tackle the challenge together
      Sponsored Content Provided By Optum
      Why CIOs went from back-office operators to mission-critical innovators
  • Awards
    • Award Programs
    • Nominate
    • Previous Award Programs
    • Other Award Programs
    • Best Places to Work in Healthcare Logo for Navigation
      Nominations Open - Best Places to Work in Healthcare
      Nominations Open - Health Care Hall of Fame
      Nominations Open - 50 Most Influential Clinical Executives
    • 100 Most Influential People
    • 50 Most Influential Clinical Executives
    • Best Places to Work in Healthcare
    • Health Care Hall of Fame
    • Healthcare Marketing Impact Awards
    • Top 25 Emerging Leaders
    • Top 25 Innovators
    • Top 25 Minority Leaders
    • Top 25 Women Leaders
    • Excellence in Nursing Awards
    • Design Awards
    • Top 25 COOs in Healthcare
    • 100 Top Hospitals
    • ACHE Awards
  • Events
    • Conferences
    • Galas
    • Webinars
    • COVID-19 Event Tracker
    • bright.md logo lockup webinar
      Sponsored Content Provided By Bright.md
      Webinar: Enabling a hybrid care model — Streamlining the patient path to both telehealth and in-person care
    • Leadership Symposium
    • Healthcare Transformation Summit
    • Women Leaders in Healthcare Conference
    • Workplace of the Future Conference
    • Strategic Marketing Conference
    • Social Determinants of Health Symposium
    • Best Places to Work Awards Gala
    • Health Care Hall of Fame Gala
    • Top 25 Minority Leaders Gala (2022)
    • Top 25 Women Leaders Gala
  • Listen
    • Podcast - Next Up
    • Podcast - Beyond the Byline
    • Sponsored Podcast - Healthcare Insider
    • Video Series - The Check Up
    • Sponsored Video Series - One on One
    • Dr. Karen DeSalvo
      Next Up Podcast: What to expect with telehealth and healthcare technology in the next four years
      Carter Dredge
      Next Up Podcast: Ready, set, innovate! Innovation and disruption in healthcare
      Next Up Podcast: COVID-19, social determinants highlight health inequities — what next?
      Ceci Connolly
      Next Up Podcast: How to navigate the murky post-election waters
    • Beyond the Byline: Regulators aim to boost value push with fraud and abuse law updates
      An older man wearing a mask receiving a vaccine.
      Beyond the Byline: Verifying information on the chaotic COVID-19 vaccine rollout
      doctor burnout
      Beyond the Byline: How healthcare supply chain struggles contribute to employee burnout
      Beyond the Byline: Covering race and diversity in the healthcare industry
    • Leading intention promote diversity and inclusion
      Introducing Healthcare Insider Podcast
    • The Check Up: Dr. Joseph Kerschner
      The Check Up: Dr. Joseph Kerschner of the Medical College of Wisconsin
      The Check Up: Chip Kahn
      The Check Up: Chip Kahn of the Federation of American Hospitals
      The Check Up: Trenda Ray
      The Check Up: Trenda Ray of the University of Arkansas for Medical Sciences
      The Check Up: Dr. Kenneth Davis
      The Check Up: Dr. Kenneth Davis of Mount Sinai Health System
    • Video: Ivana Naeymi Rad of Intelligent Medical Objects
  • MORE +
    • Advertise
    • Media Kit
    • Newsletters
    • Jobs
    • People on the Move
    • Reprints & Licensing
MENU
Breadcrumb
  1. Home
  2. Finance
January 24, 2017 12:00 AM

Aetna jeopardized its antitrust case and the ACA by exiting some exchanges

Shelby Livingston
  • Tweet
  • Share
  • Share
  • Email
  • More
    Print
    Aetna CEO Mark Bertolini testifies about the competitive effects of the proposed Humana deal before a House committee in September 2015.

    A federal judge said Aetna worsened its chances for closing its $37 billion merger with Humana when it pulled out of several Affordable Care Act insurance exchanges. Aetna had said it was due to financial losses.

    U.S. District Judge John Bates Monday blocked the $37 billion tie-up. According to his opinion, Aetna leadership made good on repeated threats to the U.S. Justice Department and then-HHS Secretary Sylvia Mathews Burwell to curtail its participation in the exchanges if the merger were blocked.

    This strategy, depicted in transcripts of phone calls, emails, depositions and internal documents throughout the opinion, not only worsened Aetna's chances of closing the merger, but also jeopardized the ACA exchanges.

    Aetna's retreat from the exchanges was and still is “a big deal,” said Craig Garthwaite, a health economist at Northwestern University. Not only did its exit reduce competition and choice for consumers in certain exchange markets, but it gave an “impression to people that the marketplaces are failing” and “that's totally inaccurate,” he said.

    Aetna chose not to comment on this story.

    Aetna announced it would drastically scale back its 2017 participation on the individual insurance markets in August 2016, a month after the Justice Department filed a lawsuit to block the Humana merger. Aetna pulled out of exchanges in 11 states, forcing hundreds of thousands of plan members to find a new insurer. It remained in just four states.

    The retreat was unexpected at the time, since Aetna just months before seemed optimistic about the future of the marketplaces. Aetna Chairman and CEO Mark Bertolini even told investment analysts in April that the insurer was on track to break even on the exchanges in 2016.

    Aetna's tune changed after releasing its second-quarter earnings for 2016. The Hartford, Conn.-based insurer announced it would pull out of the marketplaces in light of financial losses from the exchange plans totaling $200 million. Aetna has since said it expects to incur a pre-tax loss of $350 million from exchange plans for 2016.

    Citing their own financial losses, UnitedHealth Group and Humana had announced earlier in the year that they too would scale back their participation in the exchanges, as had other smaller insurers. More than a dozen health co-ops had also failed.

    But Aetna's decision was puzzling, Garthwaite said. It made more sense that UnitedHealth would pull out, because it was offering broader networks on the exchanges that could open it up to higher costs, and it didn't have much experience insuring the largely low-income people who enrolled in exchange plans. UnitedHealth was also hesitant about the exchanges from the start. But Aetna had more experience insuring a low-income population, and it employed narrower networks, Garthwaite said.

    In the court opinion, Bates concluded that Aetna's decision to exit certain exchange markets was made to improve its litigation position and not because of business reasons.

    Aetna first used its participation in the exchanges as leverage when dealing with the Justice Department, court documents show. In one instance, Aetna Executive Vice President Steven Kelmar told Burwell that Aetna “would likely have to revisit its plans for and presence on the public exchanges” if the merger were blocked. Kelmar also later sent Bertolini “talking points” that promised Aetna would remain committed to the ACA exchanges if the deal closed. But if the merger were blocked, the $1 billion break-up fee required of Aetna would impact the insurers' business and have tough consequences for the market.

    Bertolini told Burwell over the phone in June that were she to be contacted by the Justice Department regarding the merger, he would “appreciate a good word for all that we've done with you,” according to the opinion. Bertolini's discussions become more specific in July, when he wrote a letter to the Justice Department stating he would immediately reduce Aetna's exchange footprint in 2017 and withdraw from at least five different states, or possibly the public exchange business altogether, if the Justice Department sought to block the deal, court documents show.

    When the Justice Department filed a lawsuit to halt the merger, Bertolini complained in a letter to Ron Williams, the former CEO of Aetna, that “the administration has a very short memory, absolutely no loyalty and a very thin skin,” the opinion showed.

    The Justice Department's complaint against the merger said it would harm people in 17 counties in Florida, Georgia and Missouri where Aetna and Humana competed on the exchanges. Court documents show that Aetna leadership began contemplating an exit from those counties soon after. They then tried to “conceal from discovery in this litigation the reasoning behind their recommendation to withdraw from the 17 complaint counties,” Bates wrote. For instance, Aetna's head of the national exchange business warned against putting any of the team's discussions in writing, according to court documents.

    Bates also said Aetna's leadership did not evaluate the profitability of the individual business in those counties before deciding to withdraw as it had for other markets it planned to exit, Bates wrote. In fact, Florida was projected to be profitable in 2017, but Aetna pulled out anyway.

    “The inescapable conclusion from these contemporaneous emails and documents is that the Aetna team making recommendations to Bertolini did not view withdrawing from the 17 complaint counties as a business decision,” the opinion stated.

    Bates determined that Aetna is likely to return at some point after this year to some of the markets it left, so he evaluated those markets for anticompetitive effects. He found that the merger would substantially reduce competition in three Florida counties.

    Some statements in the opinion shed light on how Bates' viewed what he saw as Aetna's strategy to dodge judicial scrutiny. He wrote that courts shouldn't allow a company to “thwart judicial review through its own machinations,” and that doing so would “create incentives for firms to take similar actions in the future to evade antitrust review.”

    While Bates' decision ultimately rested on the potential merger effects in the Medicare Advantage market, the maneuvering hurt Aetna's case, experts said.

    “Judge Bates viewed that decision as gamesmanship, and it likely cast a pall over many of the arguments that Aetna chose to proffer,” said Andrea Murino, partner and co-chair of the antitrust group at law firm Goodwin Procter.

    Most importantly, Aetna's exit damaged the state of the exchanges. While it wasn't the only insurer that announced plans to exit certain marketplaces in 2017, its withdrawal reduced options for consumers.

    Just 167 insurers are selling coverage through the exchanges this year, down from 232 in 2016, according to HHS data. Across the 39 states using the federal exchange, 15 insurers entered the market for 2017, while 83 insurers stopped offering exchange coverage. Aetna accounted for a large chunk of those exits.

    According to the Kaiser Family Foundation, 1,021 U.S. counties have just one insurer selling coverage this year, compared to 225 in 2016. Because other smaller insurers may have exited exchanges around the same time as Aetna, it's difficult to say which of these counties, if any, was left with a sole insurer because of Aetna's retreat, said Cynthia Cox, an associate director at the Kaiser Family Foundation who studies the ACA's exchange markets.

    Of the 17 counties in Florida, Georgia and Missouri that Aetna exited, just one was left with a single insurer this year, though five counties have just two insurers, Kaiser data showed. Multiple insurers are necessary to create competition and hold down costs.

    Public perception of the health of the exchanges, though, may have been most affected. Aetna's exit “raised alarm bells” and made it feel like the marketplaces were “in imminent danger,” Cox said. Aetna, with 23.1 million members, is one of the country's largest insurers.

    Would-be consumers on the fence about enrolling in exchange coverage may have decided against it after hearing that Aetna, along with both UnitedHealth and Humana, were calling it quits, Garthwaite said. That's especially troubling since the exchange have been struggling to enroll enough people to stabilize the risk pool and reduce premiums, he said.

    The exchanges have been plagued by low enrollment, and those that have signed up tend to be older and sicker, making them more expensive to insure.

    Letter
    to the
    Editor

    Send us a letter

    Have an opinion about this story? Click here to submit a Letter to the Editor, and we may publish it in print.

    Recommended for You
    KPMG says deal activity will stay high in '21: 10 takeaways
    KPMG says deal activity will stay high in '21: 10 takeaways
    By the Numbers: 20 largest healthcare investment banks in 2020
    By the Numbers: 20 largest healthcare investment banks in 2020
    Sponsored Content
    Get Free Newsletters

    Sign up for free enewsletters and alerts to receive breaking news and in-depth coverage of healthcare events and trends, as they happen, right to your inbox.

    Subscribe Today

    The weekly magazine, websites, research and databases provide a powerful and all-encompassing industry presence. We help you make informed business decisions and lead your organizations to success.

    Subscribe
    Connect with Us
    • LinkedIn
    • Twitter
    • Facebook
    • RSS
    • Instagram

    Stay Connected

    Join the conversation with Modern Healthcare through our social media pages

    MDHC_Logotype_white
    Contact Us

    (877) 812-1581

    Email us

     

    Resources
    • Contact Us
    • Advertise with Us
    • Ad Choices Ad Choices
    • Sitemap
    Editorial Dept
    • Submission Guidelines
    • Code of Ethics
    • Awards
    • About Us
    Legal
    • Terms and Conditions
    • Privacy Policy
    • Privacy Request
    Modern Healthcare
    Copyright © 1996-2021. Crain Communications, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
    • News
      • This Week's News
      • COVID-19
      • Providers
      • Insurance
      • Government
      • Finance
      • Technology
      • Safety & Quality
      • People
      • Regional News
        • Midwest
        • Northeast
        • South
        • West
      • Digital Edition
    • Insights
      • ACA 10 Years After
      • Best Practices
      • InDepth Special Reports
      • Innovations
    • Transformation
      • Patients
      • Operations
      • Care Delivery
      • Payment
    • Data/Lists
      • Rankings/Lists
      • Interactive Databases
      • Data Points
    • Op-Ed
      • Bold Moves
      • Breaking Bias
      • Commentaries
      • Letters
      • Vital Signs Blog
      • From the Editor
    • Awards
      • Award Programs
        • 100 Most Influential People
        • 50 Most Influential Clinical Executives
        • Best Places to Work in Healthcare
        • Health Care Hall of Fame
        • Healthcare Marketing Impact Awards
        • Top 25 Emerging Leaders
        • Top 25 Innovators
        • Top 25 Minority Leaders
        • Top 25 Women Leaders
      • Nominate
      • Previous Award Programs
        • Excellence in Nursing Awards
        • Design Awards
        • Top 25 COOs in Healthcare
      • Other Award Programs
        • 100 Top Hospitals
        • ACHE Awards
    • Events
      • Conferences
        • Leadership Symposium
        • Healthcare Transformation Summit
        • Women Leaders in Healthcare Conference
        • Workplace of the Future Conference
        • Strategic Marketing Conference
        • Social Determinants of Health Symposium
      • Galas
        • Best Places to Work Awards Gala
        • Health Care Hall of Fame Gala
        • Top 25 Minority Leaders Gala (2022)
        • Top 25 Women Leaders Gala
      • Webinars
      • COVID-19 Event Tracker
    • Listen
      • Podcast - Next Up
      • Podcast - Beyond the Byline
      • Sponsored Podcast - Healthcare Insider
      • Video Series - The Check Up
      • Sponsored Video Series - One on One
    • MORE +
      • Advertise
      • Media Kit
      • Newsletters
      • Jobs
      • People on the Move
      • Reprints & Licensing