Skip to main content
Sister Publication Links
  • ESG: THE NEW IMPERATIVE
Subscribe
  • My Account
  • Login
  • Subscribe
  • News
    • Current News
    • COVID-19
    • Providers
    • Insurance
    • Government
    • Finance
    • Technology
    • Safety & Quality
    • Transformation
    • People
    • Regional News
    • Digital Edition (Web Version)
    • Patients
    • Operations
    • Care Delivery
    • Payment
    • Midwest
    • Northeast
    • South
    • West
  • Digital Health
  • Insights
    • ACA 10 Years After
    • Best Practices
    • Special Reports
    • Innovations
  • Data/Lists
    • Rankings/Lists
    • Interactive Databases
    • Data Points
  • Op-Ed
    • Bold Moves
    • Breaking Bias
    • Commentaries
    • Letters
    • Vital Signs Blog
    • From the Editor
  • Awards
    • Nominate/Eligibility
    • 100 Most Influential People
    • 50 Most Influential Clinical Executives
    • Best Places to Work in Healthcare
    • Excellence in Governance
    • Health Care Hall of Fame
    • Healthcare Marketing Impact Awards
    • Top 25 Emerging Leaders
    • Top 25 Innovators
    • Diversity in Healthcare
    • Women in Healthcare
    • - Luminaries
    • - Top 25 Diversity Leaders
    • - Leaders to Watch
    • - Luminaries
    • - Top 25 Women Leaders
    • - Women to Watch
  • Events
    • Conferences
    • Galas
    • Virtual Briefings
    • Webinars
    • Custom Media Event: ESG Summit
    • Transformation Summit
    • Women Leaders in Healthcare Conference
    • Social Determinants of Health Symposium
    • Leadership Symposium
    • Health Care Hall of Fame Gala
    • Top 25 Women Leaders Gala
    • Best Places to Work Awards Gala
    • Top 25 Diversity Leaders Gala
    • - Hospital of the Future
    • - Value Based Care
    • - Supply Chain Revenue Cycle
    • - Hospital at Home
    • - Workplace of the Future
    • - Strategic Marketing
    • - Virtual Health
  • Listen
    • Podcast - Next Up
    • Podcast - Beyond the Byline
    • Sponsored Podcast - Healthcare Insider
    • Video Series - The Check Up
    • Sponsored Video Series - One on One
  • MORE +
    • Advertise
    • Media Kit
    • Newsletters
    • Jobs
    • People on the Move
    • Reprints & Licensing
MENU
Breadcrumb
  1. Home
  2. Finance
May 09, 2016 01:00 AM

Judge delivers FTC rare healthcare loss in Pennsylvania hospital case

Lisa Schencker
  • Tweet
  • Share
  • Share
  • Email
  • More
    Reprints Print
    Penn State Hershey Medical Center

    (Updated at 8:15 p.m. ET)

    In a rare loss for the Federal Trade Commission in a hospital merger case, a federal judge declined Monday to temporarily block a union between Penn State Hershey Medical Center and PinnacleHealth System.

    The ruling is an unusual setback for the FTC, which has otherwise prevailed in a string of cases against hospital mergers in recent years. Hospitals and insurers across the country have been watching the Pennsylvania case and several others as mergers continue to proliferate. The loss comes as the FTC pursues an injunction in a hospital merger case in the Chicago area between Advocate HealthCare and NorthShore University HealthSystem.

    Martin Gaynor, a former director of the FTC's Bureau of Competition, called the judge's decision Monday “a big deal.” “The FTC has been on a roll” with wins, said Gaynor, now an economics professor at Carnegie Mellon University. “This is certainly a reversal.”

    U.S. District Judge John Jones III rejected the FTC's request for a preliminary injunction to stop the merger between Penn State Hershey, a 508-bed, not-for-profit health system in Dauphin County, and PinnacleHealth System, a not-for-profit, three-campus system with 607 beds, also in Dauphin County. He also slammed the FTC in his opinion for its opposition to such mergers in the current healthcare environment.

    He wrote that the FTC too narrowly defined the systems' geographic market because the agency didn't account for the distances many of their patients travel to reach the hospitals. He also wrote that the FTC did not include enough hospitals in its definition of the market.

    Jones also wrote that he found it “compelling” that the hospitals have already worked with central Pennsylvania's two largest insurers, CBC and Highmark, to ensure their rates wouldn't increase following a merger.

    “In sum, we find based on the hours of testimony and thousands of pages of exhibits presented by the parties and considered by this court, that the FTC's four-county 'Harrisburg Area' relevant geographic market is unrealistically narrow and does not assume the commercial realities faced by consumers in the region,” Jones wrote.

    He said the FTC did not demonstrate a likelihood of winning the case in its request for a preliminary injunction.

    Attempts to reach the FTC for comment Monday afternoon were not immediately successful. The FTC could appeal the decision in federal appeals court, but the commission often drops its merger challenges when it loses at the preliminary injunction stage.

    The FTC alleges the merger would lead to higher prices and diminished quality. The merged system, according to the commission's complaint, would control about 64% of the south-central Pennsylvania market.

    Several health systems battling FTC challenges since the passage of the Affordable Care Act have argued that the law's incentives to provide more coordinated and efficient care create an imperative for them to consolidate. In several big cases, that strategy has failed in court.

    The judge in the Pennsylvania case, however, wrote that his opinion “recognizes a growing need for all those involved to adapt to an evolving landscape of healthcare that includes, among other changes, the institution of the Affordable Care Act, fluctuations in Medicare and Medicaid reimbursement, and the adoption of risk-based contracting.”

    He wrote that it's better for patients if hospitals merge and survive rather than remain apart and die.

    “Our determination reflects the healthcare world as it is, and not as the FTC wishes it to be,” Jones wrote. “We find it no small irony that the same federal government under which the FTC operates has created a climate that virtually compels institutions to seek alliances such as the hospitals intended here.”

    The health systems remain committed to their integration plan, Dr. A. Craig Hillemeier, CEO of Penn State Health, said in a statement Monday.

    “Judge Jones' decision reinforces our long-stated position that the proposed integration of PinnacleHealth and the Milton S. Hershey Medical Center is to the benefit of patients, families, employers and our broader community,” said Hillemeier, who would be the CEO of the new organization.

    PinnacleHealth CEO Michael Young also said in a statement Monday he's grateful to the many employers, community physicians, insurers and other who have lent their support to the merger. Young is slated to serve as president and chief operating officer of the merged entity.

    Last year, a federal appeals court ruled against an acquisition in Idaho by St. Luke's Health System of a major medical practice in an FTC challenge. Also last year, the U.S. Supreme Court denied Ohio health system ProMedica's request to review a ruling in another FTC case that its 2010 hospital deal violated antitrust laws.

    It's hard to say whether the judge's ruling Monday is an anomaly or signals a reversal of fortune for the government's antitrust enforcement in hospital cases, Gaynor said. Closing arguments in the Advocate-NorthShore preliminary injunction hearing are scheduled for later this month in U.S. District Court in Chicago.

    Tim Greaney, a former assistant chief in charge of healthcare antitrust enforcement at the Justice Department, agreed the judge's decision Monday seems to break the FTC's winning streak.

    Greaney, now co-director of the Center for Health Law Studies at St. Louis University School of Law, said he found it surprising that the judge's opinion didn't seem to give much credence to the FTC's arguments that the combined systems would have leverage to raise prices. In the past, he said, there has beem skepticism of commitments like the one Pinnacle and Penn State Hershey made not to raise rates.

    Letter
    to the
    Editor

    Send us a letter

    Have an opinion about this story? Click here to submit a Letter to the Editor, and we may publish it in print.

    Recommended for You
    Vaccines
    Pfizer to offer low-cost medicines, vaccines to poor nations
    Cleveland Clinic
    Clinic's capital plan focuses on research
    Sponsored Content
    Daily Finance Newsletter: Sign up to receive daily news and data that has a direct impact on the business and financing of healthcare.
    Get Newsletters

    Sign up for enewsletters and alerts to receive breaking news and in-depth coverage of healthcare events and trends, as they happen, right to your inbox.

    Subscribe Today
    MH Magazine Cover

    MH magazine offers content that sheds light on healthcare leaders’ complex choices and touch points—from strategy, governance, leadership development and finance to operations, clinical care, and marketing.

    Subscribe
    Connect with Us
    • LinkedIn
    • Twitter
    • Facebook
    • RSS

    Our Mission

    Modern Healthcare empowers industry leaders to succeed by providing unbiased reporting of the news, insights, analysis and data.

    Contact Us

    (877) 812-1581

    Email us

     

    Resources
    • Contact Us
    • Advertise with Us
    • Ad Choices Ad Choices
    • Sitemap
    Editorial Dept
    • Submission Guidelines
    • Code of Ethics
    • Awards
    • About Us
    Legal
    • Terms and Conditions
    • Privacy Policy
    • Privacy Request
    Modern Healthcare
    Copyright © 1996-2022. Crain Communications, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
    • News
      • Current News
      • COVID-19
      • Providers
      • Insurance
      • Government
      • Finance
      • Technology
      • Safety & Quality
      • Transformation
        • Patients
        • Operations
        • Care Delivery
        • Payment
      • People
      • Regional News
        • Midwest
        • Northeast
        • South
        • West
      • Digital Edition (Web Version)
    • Digital Health
    • Insights
      • ACA 10 Years After
      • Best Practices
      • Special Reports
      • Innovations
    • Data/Lists
      • Rankings/Lists
      • Interactive Databases
      • Data Points
    • Op-Ed
      • Bold Moves
      • Breaking Bias
      • Commentaries
      • Letters
      • Vital Signs Blog
      • From the Editor
    • Awards
      • Nominate/Eligibility
      • 100 Most Influential People
      • 50 Most Influential Clinical Executives
      • Best Places to Work in Healthcare
      • Excellence in Governance
      • Health Care Hall of Fame
      • Healthcare Marketing Impact Awards
      • Top 25 Emerging Leaders
      • Top 25 Innovators
      • Diversity in Healthcare
        • - Luminaries
        • - Top 25 Diversity Leaders
        • - Leaders to Watch
      • Women in Healthcare
        • - Luminaries
        • - Top 25 Women Leaders
        • - Women to Watch
    • Events
      • Conferences
        • Transformation Summit
        • Women Leaders in Healthcare Conference
        • Social Determinants of Health Symposium
        • Leadership Symposium
      • Galas
        • Health Care Hall of Fame Gala
        • Top 25 Women Leaders Gala
        • Best Places to Work Awards Gala
        • Top 25 Diversity Leaders Gala
      • Virtual Briefings
        • - Hospital of the Future
        • - Value Based Care
        • - Supply Chain Revenue Cycle
        • - Hospital at Home
        • - Workplace of the Future
        • - Strategic Marketing
        • - Virtual Health
      • Webinars
      • Custom Media Event: ESG Summit
    • Listen
      • Podcast - Next Up
      • Podcast - Beyond the Byline
      • Sponsored Podcast - Healthcare Insider
      • Video Series - The Check Up
      • Sponsored Video Series - One on One
    • MORE +
      • Advertise
      • Media Kit
      • Newsletters
      • Jobs
      • People on the Move
      • Reprints & Licensing