Skip to main content
Subscribe
  • Sign Up Free
  • Login
  • Subscribe
  • News
    • Current News
    • Providers
    • Insurance
    • Government
    • Finance
    • Technology
    • Safety & Quality
    • Digital Health
    • Transformation
    • ESG
    • People
    • Regional News
    • Digital Edition (Web Version)
    • Patients
    • Operations
    • Care Delivery
    • Payment
    • Midwest
    • Northeast
    • South
    • West
  • Opinion
    • Bold Moves
    • Breaking Bias
    • Commentaries
    • Letters
    • Vital Signs Blog
    • From the Editor
  • Events & Awards
    • Awards
    • Conferences
    • Galas
    • Virtual Briefings
    • Webinars
    • Nominate/Eligibility
    • 100 Most Influential People
    • 50 Most Influential Clinical Executives
    • Best Places to Work in Healthcare
    • Excellence in Governance
    • Health Care Hall of Fame
    • Healthcare Marketing Impact Awards
    • Top 25 Emerging Leaders
    • Top Innovators
    • Diversity in Healthcare
      • - Luminaries
      • - Top 25 Diversity Leaders
      • - Leaders to Watch
    • Women in Healthcare
      • - Luminaries
      • - Top 25 Women Leaders
      • - Women to Watch
    • Digital Health Transformation Summit
    • ESG: The Implementation Imperative Summit
    • Leadership Symposium
    • Social Determinants of Health Symposium
    • Women Leaders in Healthcare Conference
    • Best Places to Work Awards Gala
    • Health Care Hall of Fame Gala
    • Top 25 Diversity Leaders Gala
    • Top 25 Women Leaders Gala
    • - Hospital of the Future
    • - Value Based Care
    • - Hospital at Home
    • - Workplace of the Future
    • - Digital Health
    • - Future of Staffing
    • - Hospital of the Future (Fall)
  • Multimedia
    • Podcast - Beyond the Byline
    • Sponsored Podcast - Healthcare Insider
    • Video Series - The Check Up
    • Sponsored Video Series - One on One
  • Data Center
    • Data Center Home
    • Hospital Financials
    • Staffing & Compensation
    • Quality & Safety
    • Mergers & Acquisitions
    • Data Archive
    • Resource Guide: By the Numbers
    • Surveys
    • Data Points
  • Newsletters
  • MORE+
    • Contact Us
    • Advertise
    • Media Kit
    • Jobs
    • People on the Move
    • Reprints & Licensing
MENU
Breadcrumb
  1. Home
  2. Insurance
December 02, 2015 12:00 AM

Supreme Court justices' questions hint at leanings in healthcare data case

Lisa Schencker
  • Tweet
  • Share
  • Share
  • Email
  • More
    Reprints Print

    During oral arguments Wednesday, several U.S. Supreme Court justices hinted how they might rule in a case that some say could hinder states' healthcare reform efforts.

    Gobeille v. Liberty Mutual Insurance Co. centers on whether a self-funded insurer should have to turn over certain information—such as on claims and member eligibility—to the state of Vermont for its all-payer database.

    The state argues it needs the data to improve the cost and effectiveness of healthcare. It argues that a ruling against it could limit reform efforts not only in Vermont, but also in other states with similar databases. That could affect as many as 18 states, according to a recent New England Journal of Medicine article. About 63% of covered workers are enrolled in a plan that is either partially or totally self-funded, according to the Kaiser Family Foundation.

    Liberty Mutual, however, says that the federal Employer Retirement Income Security Act, known as ERISA, protects it and its administrator from having to share that information. The insurer argues that ERISA pre-empts the state law, and that pre-emption is important because insurers would otherwise have to spend precious time and money navigating different states' laws for data collection, hurting both the insurers and their beneficiaries.

    The American Hospital Association, American Medical Association and Association of American Medical Colleges, among others have filed briefs supporting Vermont in the case. Insurance industry group America's Health Insurance Plans and the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, among others, have filed briefs supporting the insurer.

    During oral arguments Wednesday, Justice Stephen Breyer presented the most persistent line of questioning, repeatedly wondering why the state couldn't simply go to a federal agency such as the Labor Department or HHS for a rule allowing such data collection. Such a rule or regulation, Breyer argued, could solve the issue, allowing data collection without subjecting insurers to dozens of different state laws.

    On one hand, Breyer said, states should be able to get the information, but “there is a problem of burden” for insurers.

    “I think there are probably 100 or 200 people in the Department of Labor and HHS that could write (regulations) that reconcile these problems and allow both,” Breyer said. “I can't, because I'm a judge. So what I'm trying to figure out is how to interpret this statute in a way that achieves those objectives.”

    If Breyer's line of reasoning were to carry the day that likely wouldn't bode well for Vermont in the case, acknowledged Mike Donofrio, general counsel for the Vermont Green Mountain Care Board, which appealed the case to the Supreme Court.

    Donofrio called Breyer's line of questioning on the issue the most unexpected part of the oral arguments.

    At least two other justices, however, expressed skepticism over Breyer's idea. Justice Antonin Scalia said it's not clear that a federal agency could eliminate the problem by simply giving states permission to collect data.

    Justice Elena Kagan also said, “That sounds like a one-size-fits-all solution, and there's some value to states being able to think about their own healthcare needs.”

    Kagan aimed many of her questions Wednesday morning at Seth Waxman, the attorney for Liberty Mutual. She questioned the burden on insurers of reporting such data to states.

    Justice Sonia Sotomayor also wanted to know how easily insurers could gather and share such information. Waxman said it's not as simple as pressing a button.

    “This requires that we keep records that we don't keep, and that we display them and provide information in ways that we don't, and that differ from one state to another,” Waxman said.

    Meanwhile Vermont Solicitor General Bridget Asay said that the reporting and data collection seems complicated not because of anything Vermont has done, but rather because of standardized national procedures for how data is collected under the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act.

    Scalia's questions also seemed to focus on what constituted a burden for insurers and seemed friendlier to the insurer's side of the argument, said Howard Shapiro, a partner at Proskauer who works on ERISA issues. But Shapiro cautioned, “It's always a mistake to try to read the tea leaves from the questions because the questions are designed to expand and explore intellectual points rather than to advertise how the justice is going to write his or her opinion.”

    Overall, the justices seemed concerned Wednesday about issues on both sides of the case, said Steve Wojcik, vice president for public policy with the National Business Group on Health, an association representing large employers on healthcare and health benefits.

    “The justices seemed sympathetic to the idea that this could open the floodgates to a very burdensome situation for ERISA plans,” Wojcik said. “On the other hand there was a feeling that the state has a legitimate right to this type of information.”

    Wojcik called it a “very significant” case for ERISA because it could help define which state laws and regulations are pre-empted by the federal law.

    Shapiro also said it's an important case “because we have this cauldron brewing both politically and socially about healthcare, and the advocates for the Vermont statute and for these other types of all-payer claims databases view this effort as a way to improve healthcare.”

    A lower court, the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, already ruled in the case that ERISA does take precedence over state law, meaning Liberty Mutual's third-party administrator shouldn't have to turn over the data.

    Letter
    to the
    Editor

    Send us a letter

    Have an opinion about this story? Click here to submit a Letter to the Editor, and we may publish it in print.

    Recommended for You
    diversity2_i.png
    How Connecticut's Broker Academy targets health disparities
    cybersecurity_i.jpg
    Massachusetts health insurer faces ransomware attack, member data at risk
    Most Popular
    1
    More healthcare organizations at risk of credit default, Moody's says
    2
    Centene fills out senior executive team with new president, COO
    3
    SCAN, CareOregon plan to merge into the HealthRight Group
    4
    Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan unveils big push that lets physicians take on risk, reap rewards
    5
    Bright Health weighs reverse stock split as delisting looms
    Sponsored Content
    Daily Finance Newsletter: Sign up to receive daily news and data that has a direct impact on the business and financing of healthcare.
    Get Newsletters

    Sign up for enewsletters and alerts to receive breaking news and in-depth coverage of healthcare events and trends, as they happen, right to your inbox.

    Subscribe Today
    MH Magazine Cover

    MH magazine offers content that sheds light on healthcare leaders’ complex choices and touch points—from strategy, governance, leadership development and finance to operations, clinical care, and marketing.

    Subscribe
    Connect with Us
    • LinkedIn
    • Twitter
    • Facebook
    • RSS

    Our Mission

    Modern Healthcare empowers industry leaders to succeed by providing unbiased reporting of the news, insights, analysis and data.

    Contact Us

    (877) 812-1581

    Email us

     

    Resources
    • Contact Us
    • Advertise with Us
    • Ad Choices Ad Choices
    • Sitemap
    Editorial Dept
    • Submission Guidelines
    • Code of Ethics
    • Awards
    • About Us
    Legal
    • Terms and Conditions
    • Privacy Policy
    • Privacy Request
    Modern Healthcare
    Copyright © 1996-2023. Crain Communications, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
    • News
      • Current News
      • Providers
      • Insurance
      • Government
      • Finance
      • Technology
      • Safety & Quality
      • Digital Health
      • Transformation
        • Patients
        • Operations
        • Care Delivery
        • Payment
      • ESG
      • People
      • Regional News
        • Midwest
        • Northeast
        • South
        • West
      • Digital Edition (Web Version)
    • Opinion
      • Bold Moves
      • Breaking Bias
      • Commentaries
      • Letters
      • Vital Signs Blog
      • From the Editor
    • Events & Awards
      • Awards
        • Nominate/Eligibility
        • 100 Most Influential People
        • 50 Most Influential Clinical Executives
        • Best Places to Work in Healthcare
        • Excellence in Governance
        • Health Care Hall of Fame
        • Healthcare Marketing Impact Awards
        • Top 25 Emerging Leaders
        • Top Innovators
        • Diversity in Healthcare
          • - Luminaries
          • - Top 25 Diversity Leaders
          • - Leaders to Watch
        • Women in Healthcare
          • - Luminaries
          • - Top 25 Women Leaders
          • - Women to Watch
      • Conferences
        • Digital Health Transformation Summit
        • ESG: The Implementation Imperative Summit
        • Leadership Symposium
        • Social Determinants of Health Symposium
        • Women Leaders in Healthcare Conference
      • Galas
        • Best Places to Work Awards Gala
        • Health Care Hall of Fame Gala
        • Top 25 Diversity Leaders Gala
        • Top 25 Women Leaders Gala
      • Virtual Briefings
        • - Hospital of the Future
        • - Value Based Care
        • - Hospital at Home
        • - Workplace of the Future
        • - Digital Health
        • - Future of Staffing
        • - Hospital of the Future (Fall)
      • Webinars
    • Multimedia
      • Podcast - Beyond the Byline
      • Sponsored Podcast - Healthcare Insider
      • Video Series - The Check Up
      • Sponsored Video Series - One on One
    • Data Center
      • Data Center Home
      • Hospital Financials
      • Staffing & Compensation
      • Quality & Safety
      • Mergers & Acquisitions
      • Data Archive
      • Resource Guide: By the Numbers
      • Surveys
      • Data Points
    • Newsletters
    • MORE+
      • Contact Us
      • Advertise
      • Media Kit
      • Jobs
      • People on the Move
      • Reprints & Licensing