Join, Follow & Connect
Join Modern Healthcare's LinkedIn group Follow Modern Healthcare on Twitter Join Modern Healthcare's Facebook group Follow Modern Healthcare's Pinterest board Modern Healthcare's Flickr page Modern Healthcare's YouTube Channel Get a Modern Healthcare news feed

 
Comment Buy Reprints Print Article Share on LinkedIn Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Email this page to a colleague
Healthcare Business News
 

Years of training is wrong focus in NP vs. MD discussions


Posted: September 26, 2012 - 12:01 am ET
Tags:

Regarding "Nurses group: AAFP 'out of step' on medical-home leadership": Discussions about nurse-practitioner and medical-doctor practice almost always come down to who has the most education, the most experience or the longest time being trained. The essential question really should be, "What level of education, experience and length of time in training is optimal for providing a given level of care?" To the best of my knowledge, no one has researched the effect of length of education on patient outcomes, per se. European medical education is not based on the four years of undergraduate and four years of medical education that American physicians receive, yet European primary-care patients seem to be doing quite well. By extension, then, isn't it possible that something other than the 4 + 4 model provides the appropriate level of education, without overdoing it? A nuclear physicist knows a great deal more about the production of electrical energy than a licensed electrician does, but when I need the wiring in my house fixed, I don't hire a physicist. The electrician's combination of knowledge and skill is a better match for my needs. I think our patients would all be better served by moving the debate away from who has the most education and into what education and skill is the best match for primary care and how that education and skill can be gained.

Tamara Zurakowski

Practice Associate Professor

University of Pennsylvania School of Nursing

Gerontological nurse practitioner

Living Independently for Elders

Philadelphia


Advertisement | View Media Kit

 


What do you think?

Share your opinion. Send a letter to the Editor or Post a comment below.

Post a comment

Loading Comments Loading comments...

Search ModernHealthcare.com:


 

Switch to the new Modern Healthcare Daily News app

For the best experience of ModernHealthcare.com on your iPad, switch to the new Modern Healthcare app — it's optimized for your device but there is no need to download.