Join, Follow & Connect
Join Modern Healthcare's LinkedIn group Follow Modern Healthcare on Twitter Join Modern Healthcare's Facebook group Follow Modern Healthcare's Pinterest board Modern Healthcare's Flickr page Modern Healthcare's YouTube Channel Get a Modern Healthcare news feed


Window to Washington

An inside-the-beltway look at the legislative and regulatory process.
Comment Buy Reprints Print Article Share on LinkedIn Share on Facebook Share on Twitter
By Jessica Zigmond and Rich Daly

Popularity doesn't sway the Supreme Court

By Rich Daly
2:15 pm, Jun. 27

Supporters and opponents of the 2010 federal healthcare overhaul have been engaged in a furious war of words in recent weeks over whether the law could stand without the individual mandate. But the apparent attempt to influence the thinking of the U.S. Supreme Court justices appears to be based on a flimsy premise.

Underlying the root of the arguments over whether the law could or should stand without the individual mandate is the broadly acknowledged reality that the mandate is both extremely unpopular by itself and also the least popular of the law's many provisions.

That unpopularity—as well as the hostile questioning justices directed at the mandate during oral arguments—has led supporters to move from detailing the need for the mandate to arguing the law can stand without the requirement to have insurance.

But are the justices any more likely to strike the mandate because it is unpopular?

The popularity connection was most recently called into question by Monday's decision by the court to throw out most of an Arizona immigration law—and to lay the groundwork for a future constitutional challenge to its one remaining provision—despite the broad popularity of that law. For instance, a recent Pew Research Center poll echoed many others when it reported 58% of Americans supported Arizona's law, and only 38% opposed it.

In another example, most studies have found Americans broadly support campaign finance laws. For instance, a January Rasmussen poll found 58% of Americans said the nation needed new campaign finance laws. Such overwhelming public sentiment didn't stop the court from reaffirming—also this week—its 2010 Citizens United decision striking down a major campaign finance law.

So, the latest evidence suggests that whatever the court decides tomorrow it will have little to do with popular opinion.

Follow Rich Daly on Twitter @MHRDaly.

Comment Buy Reprints Print Article Share on LinkedIn Share on Facebook Share on Twitter

What do you think?

Share your opinion. Send a letter to the Editor or Post a comment below.

Post a comment

Loading Comments Loading comments...

Blog Tags



Switch to the new Modern Healthcare Daily News app

For the best experience of on your iPad, switch to the new Modern Healthcare app — it's optimized for your device but there is no need to download.